When you're making a decision being informed is key. You need, need, need to hear both sides of the story, you need to learn about how the members in question have behaved in the past so that you can better judge their credibility, you need to talk to anyone that may have been in the room/party, and if you're still unsure then ASK your fellow Generals. Get a second or third opinion. And, if all else fails, wait until Sunday and ask a section leader about it.